The Tax Authority Failed to Prove That the Trader Knew of the Fraud in the Supply Chain: Proceedings Discontinued After Seven Years
An allegation of participation in a VAT carousel is one of the most serious threats a business operating in a so-called sensitive sector can face. Being accused of involvement in a carousel scheme carries not only tax consequences, namely a refusal of the right to deduct VAT or a challenge to a VAT refund, but also the risk of criminal tax liability. Below we describe a case in which a trader in the electronics sector successfully challenged the findings of the tax authorities.
The facts: a tax audit and a carousel allegation
In 2017 the head of one of the Warsaw tax offices opened a tax audit at a business active in photography and in the wholesale of electronic and telecommunications equipment. Trade in electronics belongs to the so-called sensitive sectors, which the tax authorities treat with particular suspicion because of the frequency of irregularities found in them.
In the audit report the authority accused the trader of participating in a VAT carousel. According to the head of the office, the taxpayer had:
- overstated the value of intra-Community supplies of goods by PLN 2,800,000,
- and consequently overstated the VAT claimed for refund by PLN 400,000.
The key element of the allegation was the authority’s assumption that the invoices used by the trader were unreliable and documented transactions that had never taken place.
The first line of defence: the allegations partly refuted
Robert Nogacki, attorney at law (radca prawny) at Kancelaria Prawna Skarbiec, took up the defence of the trader against the allegation of participation in a VAT carousel and presented evidence refuting the claim that the taxpayer had knowingly taken part in a criminal scheme.
In the course of the tax proceedings the head of the tax office had to concede that he was unable to prove that part of the disputed supplies had not taken place. In January 2021 the authority issued a tax decision that partly upheld the taxpayer’s position.
The trader appealed against the decision to the extent that it remained unfavourable: the authority still refused to refund several hundred thousand zlotys of VAT.
The appeal: a landmark decision of the Director of the Tax Administration Chamber
In August 2021 the Director of the Tax Administration Chamber in Warsaw (Dyrektor Izby Administracji Skarbowej) issued a decision upholding the objections raised in the appeal. The second-instance authority found in particular that:
No evidence of unreliable invoices: the head of the tax office had identified no evidence that the disputed invoices were unreliable and had not shown that they documented transactions that never took place.
Participation in a VAT carousel not proven: the first-instance authority had not produced sufficient evidence of the trader’s knowing participation in carousel fraud.
Numerous procedural defects: the Director pointed out a series of irregularities in the way the head of the office had conducted the proceedings.
The decision of the appellate authority was almost entirely consistent with the objections raised by the trader’s counsel.
A controversial outcome: annulment instead of discontinuance
Despite finding such far-reaching defects in the conduct of the first-instance authority, the Director of the Tax Administration Chamber did not bring the case to a definitively favourable close for the taxpayer. Instead of annulling the decision and discontinuing the proceedings, which would have been the natural outcome given the lack of evidence of wrongdoing, he ordered the case to be re-examined.
Moreover, in the reasons for the decision the Director instructed the first-instance authority how it should conduct the further proceedings so as to arrive, after all, at an assessment of the tax liability.
Such conduct raises serious doubts from the standpoint of the rule of law. Since the appellate authority confirmed that the head of the office had demonstrated no irregularities on the trader’s part, the natural consequence should have been the annulment of the defective decision and the return of the funds due to the taxpayer.
Complaint to the administrative court
Given the nature of the second-instance ruling, the trader, despite the theoretically favourable annulment, decided to challenge it before the regional administrative court (wojewódzki sąd administracyjny).
As Robert Nogacki, representing the trader, summarised:
“The authority’s conduct shows a persistent determination to accuse the trader, against the logic of the evidence presented in the case. We cannot but oppose such conduct by the tax authorities, which is why we have referred the case to the regional administrative court”.
Update: how the case ended
In the end, the court never examined the complaint. Even before the Director’s decision, a few months before the limitation period for the liabilities for the audited periods was due to expire, criminal tax proceedings were initiated and the taxpayer was notified that the limitation period had been suspended (Article 70 § 6 point 1 and Article 70c of the Tax Ordinance Act, Ordynacja podatkowa), which allowed the authority to continue the case for years to come. After the Director’s decision the case returned to the head of the tax office and, despite formal reminders (ponaglenia) from the trader’s counsel, it took more than three and a half years to bring it to a close. The authority added to the file material from proceedings against the suppliers and against entities earlier in the chain, as well as witness testimony given in other cases. It found no evidence that the trader knew or should have known of the fraud.
In March 2025 the head of the tax office discontinued the proceedings as devoid of purpose (Article 208 § 1 of the Tax Ordinance Act). In the reasons he conceded that it could not be established that the taxpayer could have foreseen the intentions of its counterparties, that there was no evidence of a lack of interest in the origin of the goods, and that the doubts, of which there were many in the case, could not be resolved against the taxpayer. More than seven years passed between the opening of the audit and the discontinuance of the proceedings. The outcome was decided by documents gathered during the cooperation with the suppliers rather than after the audit began: contracts, invoices with product specifications, transfer confirmations, certificates of no tax arrears, printouts confirming the counterparties’ VAT status, consignment notes and loading records.
Practical conclusions
The case illustrates several important points about defending against an allegation of participation in a VAT carousel:
The burden of proof lies with the authority: it is the tax authority that must prove that the taxpayer knowingly participated in carousel fraud. Operating in a sensitive sector cannot by itself justify automatic challenges to transactions.
Unreliability of invoices must be proven: the authority may not assume that invoices are unreliable merely because they concern transactions in a sensitive sector. It must present specific evidence that the documented transactions did not take place.
The taxpayer’s good faith: a trader who exercised due diligence in verifying its counterparties should not bear the consequences of fraud committed by other entities in the supply chain.
The need for an active defence: a passive stance towards the allegations of the tax authorities may lead to unfavourable outcomes. An effective defence requires professional legal support and active challenge of the authority’s findings at every stage of the proceedings.
Judicial review of decisions: even a theoretically favourable decision of the appellate authority may need to be challenged if it does not definitively end the case or contains instructions that suggest a predetermined result of the renewed proceedings.
How to defend against the allegation
Businesses that have been accused of participating in a VAT carousel, or fear such an allegation, should:
- Secure the records: gather all documents confirming that the transactions were real, including contracts, correspondence, transport documents and payment confirmations.
- Demonstrate due diligence: document the counterparty verification procedures applied in the business, including checks of VAT status, business history and references.
- Seek professional help: an allegation of participation in a VAT carousel is a serious matter that calls for the support of a law firm specialising in tax disputes.
- Take an active part in the proceedings: file motions for evidence, challenge the authority’s findings and exercise the right to participate actively in the proceedings.
- Do not give hasty explanations: every statement made during a tax audit or a customs and fiscal audit can be used against the taxpayer.
Legal assistance in carousel cases
Kancelaria Prawna Skarbiec has many years’ experience in cases involving allegations of participation in VAT carousels. We represent businesses at every stage: from the tax audit, through tax proceedings and appeals, to proceedings before the administrative courts and the Supreme Administrative Court.
Where the allegations are of a criminal tax nature, we also provide defence in criminal tax proceedings.
VAT Fraud Allegations
In Polish VAT disputes the authority questions years of past returns, and the burden of proving the transactions falls on the taxpayer. We represent businesses in VAT refund cases, audits, administrative courts and related criminal-fiscal proceedings.

Founder and Managing Partner of Skarbiec Law Firm, recognized by Dziennik Gazeta Prawna as one of the best tax advisory firms in Poland (2023, 2024). Legal advisor with 19 years of experience, serving Forbes-listed entrepreneurs and innovative start-ups. One of the most frequently quoted experts on commercial and tax law in the Polish media, regularly publishing in Rzeczpospolita, Gazeta Wyborcza, and Dziennik Gazeta Prawna. Author of the publication “AI Decoding Satoshi Nakamoto. Artificial Intelligence on the Trail of Bitcoin’s Creator” and co-author of the award-winning book “Bezpieczeństwo współczesnej firmy” (Security of a Modern Company). LinkedIn profile: 18 500 followers, 4 million views per year. Awards: 4-time winner of the European Medal, Golden Statuette of the Polish Business Leader, title of “International Tax Planning Law Firm of the Year in Poland.” He specializes in strategic legal consulting, tax planning, and crisis management for business.